What broad match and AI Max actually change in your account
Before the routine below makes sense, it helps to know what you are monitoring for. Google has been moving advertisers towards more automation for years, and the latest step is the automatic upgrade of some campaigns to AI Max for Search. If your campaigns use broad match, you may find settings switched on that you never chose. The exact dates and eligibility vary, so treat the notice inside your own account as the final word. What matters for a small business is understanding what those settings do to your money.
Broad match is not the broad match you remember
Years ago, broad match was a blunt instrument. A plumber bidding on "boiler repair" could end up paying for "free plumbing course" or "boiler jobs". Today broad match is combined with Smart Bidding, and Google looks at far more than the words themselves. It considers the other keywords in the ad group, your landing page, the searcher's recent behaviour and their location. When it works, it finds enquiries you would never have thought to bid on, such as "no hot water in flat" when you only targeted "boiler repair".
The catch is that broad match is only as clever as the conversion data you feed it. If your account counts every page view or a click on your phone number in the footer as a "conversion", the system learns to chase cheap, meaningless actions. It will do exactly what you asked, just not what you meant.
What AI Max adds on top
AI Max bundles several features into existing Search campaigns. The three that matter most to a small advertiser are:
- Search term matching. Your ads can appear for searches that do not match any of your keywords, based on Google's reading of your site and assets. It behaves like broad match without needing the keyword.
- Text customisation. Google can generate headlines and descriptions from your landing page and existing ads. The wording may not be what you would have approved, and it can make claims you are not comfortable with, such as "same day service" when you only offer that on weekdays.
- Final URL expansion. Google can send someone to a page on your site other than the one you chose. A search for "boiler service" might land on your blog, your careers page or a service you barely offer.
Each of these can be useful, and each can be turned off or restricted. The problem is not that the features exist. It is that they can arrive switched on, in an account that nobody has looked at for weeks.
A worked example: a Worthing boiler engineer
Take a local heating business spending £30 a day, roughly £900 a month. Using exact and phrase match on terms like "boiler repair Worthing" and "combi boiler service", it pays an average of £3.50 a click and converts 8% of visitors into enquiries.
- £900 buys about 257 clicks.
- At 8%, that is around 20 enquiries, or about £44 each.
Now let broad matching loose with weak controls. Searches arrive for "boiler engineer jobs", "how to bleed a radiator", "boiler grants 2025" and "boiler repair Brighton" (outside the area you cover). Say 30% of clicks are irrelevant and never convert.
- 77 of those 257 clicks are wasted, costing about £270.
- The remaining 180 clicks produce around 14 enquiries.
- Cost per enquiry jumps to roughly £62, about 40% higher, for the same monthly spend.
Nothing in that account looks broken. Spend is on budget, clicks are healthy and the click-through rate may even have improved. Only cost per real enquiry tells the story, which is why the routine later in this article leans so heavily on the search terms report and your actual lead inbox.
How to find out whether your account has already changed
- Open the change history. In Google Ads, go to Tools, then Change history. Filter by date for the last 60 days and look for edits to match types, bid strategies or campaign settings that you did not make.
- Check each Search campaign's settings. Open the campaign, then Settings, and look for AI Max options, search term matching, text customisation and final URL expansion. Note which are on.
- Read the search terms report with fresh eyes. Sort by cost, not clicks. Anything expensive and unfamiliar is where the automation is wandering.
- Look at the landing pages report. If traffic is arriving on pages you never set as final URLs, expansion is active.
- Check who receives Google's emails. Notices about upgrades often go to whoever originally created the account. If that is a former agency or a colleague who has left, you may be the last to know. Update the user list under Admin, then Access and security.
Controls to put in place before you switch anything on
If you decide to try broad match or AI Max, do it deliberately and on your terms:
- Give it its own campaign and budget. Keep your proven exact and phrase match campaign untouched. Put the experiment in a separate campaign with a daily budget you could afford to lose entirely for a month.
- Set location targeting to "Presence". The default option includes people who merely show interest in your area. For a Worthing electrician, that can mean someone in Leeds reading about Sussex.
- Build negative keyword lists at account level. A starter list for most trades and services includes: jobs, careers, salary, apprenticeship, course, training, free, DIY, how to, template, and the names of competitors you do not want to appear against. Add to it every week.
- Use brand and URL exclusions. If AI Max or final URL expansion is on, exclude pages that should never receive paid traffic, such as careers, terms and blog posts, and restrict brand matching to what you intend.
- Do not hand over bidding too early. Target CPA and similar strategies need data. As a rough guide, aim for at least 30 conversions in the previous 30 days before asking Google to optimise to a cost target. With fewer, it is guessing.
- Use the Experiments feature. Google Ads lets you split a campaign 50/50 and compare the original against the changed version. Run it for four to six weeks and judge by cost per genuine enquiry.
One more detail worth knowing is how budgets behave. Google may spend up to twice your daily budget on a single day when it sees good opportunity, though over a month it should not exceed your daily budget multiplied by 30.4. If you set £30, a £58 day is not a fault. But if you are looking at spend daily without understanding this, you will either panic needlessly or miss a genuine problem.

A weekly and monthly monitoring routine that takes under an hour
Automation does not remove the need to look at your account. It changes what you look for. Put two slots in the diary and treat them like any other appointment: 20 minutes every week and 40 minutes once a month.
Weekly: 20 minutes
- Search terms report. Scan the last seven days for anything irrelevant, then add it as a negative keyword. Five minutes is plenty if you do it weekly. Sort by cost, highest first, because that is where the damage sits. When you add a negative, choose the match type with care. A phrase match negative on "jobs" blocks "boiler jobs Sussex" and "plumbing jobs near me" alike. An exact match negative on "boiler repair brighton" blocks only that precise search, which is useful when the problem is one place name rather than a whole theme. Be careful that a negative does not block something you want: adding "free" as a broad negative will also stop "free quote" searches, which may be your best leads.
- Spend versus budget pacing. Check you are not burning through the month early, or sitting well under budget for no obvious reason. A quick test: on the 10th of a 30 day month, you should have spent roughly a third of your monthly budget. If you have spent half, find out why. If you have spent a fifth, check for disapproved ads, a low bid limit or a lapsed payment method.
- Conversion count versus your lead inbox. If Google says 12 conversions and your inbox and phone log say 5 real enquiries, your tracking is flattering you. Common culprits are a conversion set up on a page view, duplicate counting (a form that fires on both submit and the thank you page), and calls from ads that last two seconds. In your conversion settings, check which actions are marked as primary, since only primary actions steer bidding. Page views and scroll depth should be secondary or removed.
- Change history. Look for any edit you did not make. Google, a colleague or a former agency may have changed something. Note that some changes are attributed to Google's own systems, which is a clue that an auto-applied recommendation has run.
While you are in there, open the Notifications and Recommendations tabs, and skim any emails from Google for announcements of auto-applied changes. Then review your auto-apply recommendations settings and switch off anything you do not want. If you would not agree to it in a meeting, it should not happen by default.
Setting up alerts that actually fire
Checking weekly is good, but a runaway day can cost you before the week is out. Two safety nets are worth ten minutes of setup:
- Automated rules. Under Tools, then Rules, you can set a rule to email you when a campaign's cost today exceeds a figure, for instance £50 if your budget is £30. You can also send an alert when a campaign has spent more than a set amount with zero conversions over the last seven days.
- The Google Ads mobile app. Turn on push notifications for budget and disapproval alerts. They are not perfect, but they will catch an obvious failure on a Saturday afternoon.
Be wary of rules that pause campaigns automatically. A paused campaign is also a lost day of enquiries, and a rule that fires on a slow Monday can cost more than it saves. Alerts that tell you are safer than rules that act for you, at least until you know your account's normal rhythm.
Monthly: 40 minutes
Once a month, zoom out and check four things:
- Cost per lead trend. Look at the direction over several months, not one noisy week. Write the figure down each month. For example, £41 in March, £44 in April, £52 in May and £61 in June is a story, even if no single month looks alarming. A rise over three consecutive months deserves action before month four.
- Impression share lost to budget and to rank. Budget means you ran out of money. Rank means your bids or ad quality were not good enough. They need different fixes. If you lose 40% of impressions to budget on a campaign that produces leads at a good price, the answer is usually more budget, moved from weaker campaigns. If you lose 40% to rank, more budget will not help. Improve the ad relevance, the landing page and the expected click-through rate instead.
- Landing page bounce rate. A high rate on a page you are paying to send people to is a quiet leak. In Google Analytics 4, look at engagement rate, which is the flip side of bounce rate. If fewer than around half of paid visitors engage, the page is not matching the promise of the ad. Check it on a phone first, since most local searches happen there.
- Asset performance. Replace headlines and descriptions rated poorly and keep what is working. Give each asset enough time, a few weeks and a good number of impressions, before judging it. If Google is generating text under AI Max, read the examples it has produced and remove anything inaccurate.
Judging results fairly
Never compare a learning period with a stable period. After a bidding or structure change, results can wobble for a couple of weeks, so a bad fortnight straight afterwards tells you little. Allow for seasonality too. A cold snap will flood a boiler engineer with enquiries whatever you do, and a mild spring will do the opposite. Other UK patterns catch people out as well: January is slow for many consumer services and busy for others, bank holiday weekends distort lead volumes, and school holidays change when families search. Where you can, compare against the same month last year as well as the previous month, so a seasonal dip does not get blamed on a new setting.
Experiment discipline and a change log
Change one structural thing per quarter. That might be switching a campaign to broad match, trialling AI Max on one extra campaign, or setting a different target. If you change three at once, you will never know which one helped or hurt.
Keep a simple spreadsheet with three columns: date, change, result. It takes a minute to update, and in six months it will be the most useful document you own. A typical entry might read: "12 May. Switched Emergency Plumber campaign to Maximise Conversions. 9 June. Cost per lead down from £58 to £49, lead quality unchanged." Another might read: "3 July. Turned on final URL expansion. 17 July. Traffic going to blog posts, cost per lead up 30%, switched back." Entries like these stop you repeating expensive mistakes and make any conversation with an agency far more productive.

When to run it yourself, when to get help, and what to ask an agency
Insufficient ongoing management is probably the biggest issue we see in UK SME accounts, especially in the first few months. Google Ads is not a campaign you build once and forget. If you cannot commit to the routine above, that is a sign to get help, not a reason to skip it.
Warning signs you need help
- You have spent for more than a month without a single lead. After four weeks, the cause is almost always something fixable, such as broken tracking, the wrong keywords, a weak landing page or a budget too small to gather data. Spending another month hoping it will improve rarely works.
- Your cost per lead has risen for three consecutive months.
- You cannot explain which keywords bring in enquiries. If you cannot say which searches produce your calls and forms, you cannot tell whether automation is helping or quietly diluting your targeting.
Questions to ask a PPC provider
- How do you structure match types, and where does broad match sit? A good answer explains that proven exact and phrase terms are protected, and that broad match is tested separately with its own budget.
- How do you handle AI Max, and will you test it before rolling it out? Listen for words like experiment, split test and control group.
- What counts as a conversion in your setup? Calls, form fills, or just page views? A strong provider will mention call length thresholds, and ideally ask you which enquiries turned into paying jobs.
- Can I see the search terms report and change history whenever I like?
Vague answers are an answer in themselves. A good provider will be happy to show you the detail.
Non-negotiables
Insist that the account is in your own name, so you can walk away with your data and history. Agencies often manage accounts through a manager account linked to yours, which is fine. What is not fine is an account created under the agency's own billing and ownership, because you may lose years of conversion data if you part ways. Ask for transparent reporting you can check against Google itself, with figures you can match to the Google Ads dashboard. Management fees should be clearly separate from ad spend, so you know exactly how much of your money reaches Google. Fees are commonly charged either as a flat monthly amount or as a percentage of spend, so ask which applies and what is included, such as landing page changes and call tracking. Be cautious of long minimum contracts, particularly in the first few months while the account is still learning.
Do not forget the landing page
Even perfectly targeted clicks are wasted if the page does not answer the query quickly. Someone searching "emergency plumber Worthing" wants a phone number and reassurance, not a company history. The basics that make the biggest difference are a tap-to-call number visible without scrolling on a phone, a headline that repeats what they searched for, proof such as reviews and your Gas Safe or NICEIC registration number, and a short form with only the fields you truly need. Pages should load in a few seconds on mobile data, and each main service should have its own page, so that an ad for "boiler service" lands on a boiler service page rather than a general homepage. That is why we build conversion-focused websites and manage PPC together, so the ad, the page and the tracking all pull in the same direction.
Five things to do today
- Check notifications. Read the Notifications and Recommendations tabs and switch off auto-apply settings you did not choose.
- Audit conversions. Make sure every counted conversion is a real enquiry. Submit a test form and make a test call, then confirm each appears once in the account.
- Review search terms. Add negatives for anything irrelevant from the last 30 days.
- Cap discovery spend. Keep any broad match or AI Max testing in its own campaign with a firm daily budget.
- Set alerts. Create notifications for sudden spend spikes and for days with no conversions.
That is an hour of work, and it is the cheapest insurance your ad budget will ever have.